O thou servant of the Holy Threshold! We have read what
flowed out from thy pen in thy love for God, and found the contents of thy
letter most pleasing. My hope is that through the bounty of God, the breaths of
the All-Merciful will at all times refresh and renew thee.
Thou didst write of reincarnation. A belief in reincarnation
goeth far back into the ancient history of almost all peoples, and was held
even by the philosophers of Greece, the Roman sages, the ancient Egyptians, and
the great Assyrians. Nevertheless such superstitions and sayings are but
absurdities in the sight of God.
The major argument of the reincarnationists was this, that
according to the justice of God, each must receive his due: whenever a man is
afflicted with some calamity, for example, this is because of some wrong he
hath committed. But take a child that is still in its mother’s womb, the embryo
but newly formed, and that child is blind, deaf, lame, defective—what sin hath
such a child committed, to deserve its afflictions? They answer that, although
to outward seeming the child, still in the womb, is guilty of no
sin—nevertheless he perpetrated some wrong when in his previous form, and thus
he came to deserve his punishment.
These individuals, however, have overlooked the following
point. If creation went forward according to only one rule, how could the
all-encompassing Power make Itself felt? How could the Almighty be the One Who
‘doeth as He pleaseth and ordaineth as He willeth’?